Tucson is a city of long sunny days, late desert evenings, and a lively mix of college students, longtime residents, and visitors. Most nights pass without incident. But when gunfire erupts beside a rental complex off a busy corridor, or a blade comes out on the sidewalk outside a bar at closing time, the aftermath can upend a life: emergency surgery at a trauma center, weeks off work, and a fear of going out that does not fade.
Arizona law does not leave those victims with nowhere to turn but the person who attacked them. If the company or landlord running the location brushed off clear warning signs, it can be made to pay.
What a negligent-security claim is
This type of lawsuit is brought in civil court against the party that owned or ran the location of the attack. It does not seek to hold the owner liable for committing the crime. Instead, it focuses on the precautions the owner skipped despite having reason to expect trouble, and on how those gaps let the attacker strike.
The claim moves on a separate track from any prosecution. It can proceed whether the person who did the shooting or stabbing is charged, acquitted, never located, or no longer alive.
Where these cases arise in Tucson
Claims in Pima County commonly involve:
- Apartment complexes and other rental housing
- Bars, nightclubs, and late-night entertainment venues
- Parking lots and parking garages
- Convenience stores and retail businesses along major commercial corridors
- Motels and hotels
- Transit stops and nearby businesses
Downtown's entertainment district, the Fourth Avenue corridor, South Sixth Avenue, midtown, and the separately incorporated City of South Tucson all see these claims.
How Arizona approaches the owner's duty
Under Arizona law, the party in control of a property owes visitors reasonable protection from outside wrongdoers whose conduct could be anticipated. Jurors usually decide two related points: what level of protection the circumstances demanded, and whether the owner delivered it.
In practice, that means the property's history is front and center. A complex where tenants were held up at gunpoint in the carport more than once, a bar with repeated fights spilling into the street, or a motel where police are called night after night presents a very different picture than a quiet location with no warning signs.
A Tucson-specific benchmark for rental housing
The Tucson Police Department participates in the Crime Free Multi-Housing program, an approach to rental-property safety that originated in Mesa, Arizona. The program involves training for managers, a security inspection of the property, and meetings with residents. Its standards for lighting, locks, landscaping, and tenant screening can serve as a reference point when evaluating whether a Tucson apartment owner took security seriously. Properties inside the City of South Tucson follow that city's own rules, which can require participation.
What to do this week
If you or someone close to you was hurt, start by getting medical care and keeping every record. Ask the Tucson Police Department or the Pima County Sheriff's Department for the report number. Write down the location within the property, the time, and anything you noticed about gates, lights, cameras, or staff. Save receipts, texts, and photos that show you were there, and politely say no to a taped conversation with the owner's insurer until a lawyer is on board.
Filing deadlines and where to file
Tucson claims usually land in Pima County's branch of the Arizona Superior Court. State law ordinarily sets a two-year window, starting with the attack, for an injured person to sue, and gives a grieving family two years from the death. Claims against public entities carry shorter, stricter notice requirements. Since surveillance video and maintenance records can vanish quickly, early legal help matters.
Shared fault and full compensation
Under Arizona's pure comparative fault system, any share of blame assigned to the victim trims the award by that percentage without wiping it out. The state constitution separately bars lawmakers from capping awards in injury and death cases, leaving treatment costs, missed wages, and human suffering fully compensable.
About the firm
The Haggard Law Firm, whose office is in Coral Gables, Florida, assists crime victims in many states. Michael A. Haggard's law license is a Florida license; the State Bar of Arizona has not admitted him. Given the firm's concentration on crime-victim cases, he joins Grand Canyon State matters with an Arizona-licensed lawyer and, when the court's rules permit, seeks a pro hac vice appearance limited to that one lawsuit. An Arizona-admitted attorney remains involved throughout.
Nearly 500 negligent-security cases stand behind the firm, along with a $102.7 million jury result, still the national record for security-negligence trials; the amount is gross.
A fee is due only if compensation is won. Tucson victims and families may reach (305) 446-5700 for a private, cost-free conversation.
Attorney advertising. The discussion of Arizona law above is educational and should not substitute for counsel on your facts; an inquiry does not by its own force make anyone your lawyer. Mr. Haggard's bar admission is Floridian, not Arizonan. Any verdict mentioned here says nothing certain about the outcome of another claim.


